Skip to Main Navigation | Skip to Article Content | This page is best viewed in Mozilla Firefox.

This page is best viewed
in Mozilla Firefox.

Teaching Guide for Graduate Student Instructors
GSI Teaching & Resource Center

Professional Development

Letters of Recommendation:
Dos and Don’ts

When working on a letter of recommendation for a student, bear in mind both practices that are helpful and ones that are unhelpful.

Do:

  • Do be specific. Mention examples of the student’s work, projects completed, activities, and so forth. If your memory is not clear, either ask the student to give you some work samples or suggest the student ask someone else who knows him or her better to write the letter.
  • Do be objective. Report examples, events, and so forth, as much as possible. If you want to attest to a student’s interpersonal skills, discuss how you observed the student’s interactions with others, rather than merely state what a “nice person” she or he is.
  • Do be both honest and positive. If you have negative things to say, ask the student to find another letter writer. Obviously, saying negative things about a student’s performance will have serious consequences on the student’s chances at the job, scholarship, or acceptance being sought. Remember that your experience with the student may not be typical, so the student should find only someone who can say positive things. In addition, writing negative things can potentially affect you as well, if there is ever any doubt about the reliability of your judgment with respect to the student.
  • Do be neat, type the letter, and check spelling and grammar. A letter that contains spelling or grammatical errors, or is sloppily presented, may not carry as much weight as one that is professionally presented and well written.
  • Do sign the letter in ink (if applicable).
  • Do supply contact information such as your name, title, institution, mailing address, email address, and telephone number.
  • Do be aware of potential ambiguities and words with negative connotations. Also, be aware that what you omit to mention may be seen as just as important as what you do mention.

Don’t:

  • Don’t use bland words such as nice, fairly, satisfactory, good. If you cannot honestly recommend the student more strongly, suggest that she or he ask someone else to write the letter.
  • Don’t refer to characteristics such as race or nationality, ethnicity, gender, religion, age, appearance, disability, marital status, etc., which could be construed as discriminatory. For example, don’t say things such as, “John did very well in my class despite his obvious disabilities….”

 

<< CHAPTER INDEX < PREVIOUS PAGE NEXT PAGE >

 

Graduate Student Instructor Teaching & Resource Center Home | Graduate Division Home | UC Berkeley Home
Questions, comments, or suggestions? Contact Us | gsi@berkeley.edu | 510-642-4456
301 Sproul Hall, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720-5900
© 2005-2011 The Regents of the University of California. All rights reserved.